Key Takeaway:


When Daron Acemoglu, Simon Johnson, and James Robinson were awarded the 2024 Nobel Memorial Prize in economics, it was a long-awaited recognition for their work connecting societal institutions to economic development. Their influential book Why Nations Fail shaped a global debate, offering a simple premise: countries succeed when they adopt “inclusive institutions” like democracy, while “extractive institutions” stifle growth by concentrating power and wealth in the hands of elites. But the theory has faced criticism for oversimplification, especially when applied to real-world examples.

Acemoglu, Johnson, and Robinson argue that inclusive institutions, which protect property rights and limit corruption, lead to economic prosperity, while extractive institutions do the opposite. This framework has certainly influenced policymakers worldwide, but it faces a significant challenge: historical evidence suggests that countries like Singapore, South Korea, and China experienced rapid growth without having these supposedly vital “inclusive institutions” in place from the start.

Critics argue that this view ignores the complex realities of economic growth. Scholars like Mushtaq Khan and Yuen Yuen Ang point out that economic progress has historically occurred even in corrupt environments, as seen in China’s meteoric rise. Moreover, Ang notes that Western countries, including the United States, were rife with corruption during their developmental stages. This raises the question of whether inclusive institutions are truly a prerequisite for growth.

The laureates also skirt the darker aspects of colonialism. Their research suggests that settler colonies like the U.S. and Australia developed stronger institutions over time, while non-settler colonies were left with extractive systems. However, this analysis largely glosses over the brutal realities of colonization, including the violence and exploitation that accompanied the imposition of these institutions. While Acemoglu has stated that their work doesn’t judge colonialism as “good or bad,” this neutral stance has been criticized for downplaying the catastrophic effects of imperialism on colonized nations.

This reluctance to engage with the moral implications of their findings reflects a broader issue within economics. The discipline often prides itself on neutrality, avoiding value judgments in favor of cold, hard data. However, this detachment from ethical considerations may limit the field’s ability to address the complex socio-economic challenges faced by the world today.

In fact, the Nobel Prize in economics itself has been criticized for its insularity. The prize, which was not part of Alfred Nobel’s original set of awards, is largely dominated by scholars from elite American institutions, perpetuating a narrow geographic and institutional focus. This year’s winners follow the trend, sparking renewed debate over whether the field is engaging deeply enough with difficult issues like colonialism, imperialism, and capitalism.

Acemoglu, Johnson, and Robinson’s work has undeniably shaped the global conversation on development, but it’s also clear that their framework has its limitations. As the world continues to grapple with economic inequality and historical injustices, a more nuanced approach is needed—one that doesn’t shy away from difficult questions about the structures that underpin global prosperity.

Recently Published

Key Takeaway: Airports often lead to unusual behavior, such as drunken brawls and flight diversions. The psychology of travel can influence this behavior, as the promise of vacation can shift our mindset into anticipation and liberation. The overwhelming noise, crowds, and constant hustle can overload our senses, leading to stress-induced irritability and unexpected outbursts. Airports […]
Key Takeaway: Over 8,500 shipwrecks from two devastating world wars pose a significant threat to marine ecosystems and coastal communities. These underwater time capsules contain up to 6 billion gallons of oil, munitions, toxic heavy metals, and chemical weapons. The degradation of these wrecks is accelerating due to rising ocean temperatures, increasing acidification, and more […]

Top Picks

Key Takeaway: South Korea’s cultural exports have surged to unprecedented heights, with the latest season of “Squid Game” solidifying its position as a global entertainment powerhouse. The “Korean Wave” or Hallyu, which includes TV series, movies, animation, and music, has generated approximately US$3.7 billion annually for South Korea through exports, consumer spending, and tourism. The […]
Key Takeaway: A study published in Nature Astronomy found a strong consensus among scientists that extraterrestrial life exists in the universe. The survey, which involved 521 astrobiologists and 534 non-astrobiologists, found that 86.6% agreed or strongly agreed that some form of extraterrestrial life exists. The study also found that 67.4% of astrobiologists and 58.2% of […]
Key Takeaway: Researchers are using genome-scale metabolic models (GEMs) to study the complexities of microbial life, offering innovative solutions to climate change and space challenges. GEMs simulate the vast network of metabolic pathways within living organisms, allowing scientists to test and predict microbial behavior across diverse environments. They provide a detailed framework for understanding organisms’ […]
Key Takeaway: The “Wirkin” bag, a $78 imitation of Hermès’ Birkin bag, has gained popularity on TikTok, attracting millions of users. The bag, a clever portmanteau of “Walmart” and “Birkin,” allows everyday consumers to partake in high-end fashion without the exorbitant cost. The trend reflects a broader shift in societal values, where symbols of wealth […]
Key Takeaway: In 2022, scientists achieved the “experiment of the century” at Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, marking the first time a fusion reaction produced more energy than consumed. This achievement has attracted billions of dollars in private investment, particularly in the United States, to advance fusion technology. However, a myriad of engineering challenges remain before […]

Trending

I highly recommend reading the McKinsey Global Institute’s new report, “Reskilling China: Transforming The World’s Largest Workforce Into Lifelong Learners”, which focuses on the country’s biggest employment challenge, re-training its workforce and the adoption of practices such as lifelong learning to address the growing digital transformation of its productive fabric. How to transform the country […]

Join our Newsletter

Get our monthly recap with the latest news, articles and resources.

Login

Welcome to Empirics

We are glad you have decided to join our mission of gathering the collective knowledge of Asia!
Join Empirics