Key Takeaway:

Buzzfeed News has announced it will shut its award-winning news division for good, laying off 60 journalists. This is bad news for those involved and a tragedy for the wider digital news media, as it produced hard-edged, scoop-heavy journalism. Media companies sought to emulate Buzzfeed’s irreverent and flippant style, but its quality journalism and news values were similar to those of The New York Times. Buzzfeed News was a legitimate news organisation that had the instincts and values of traditional reporters, despite its youth and focus on social issues.


Buzzfeed News, once a shining star of digital journalism, has announced it willย shut its award-winning news divisionย for good, laying off about 60 journalists in a move its founding editor, Ben Smith, described as โ€œthe end of the marriage between social media and newsโ€.

Buzzfeed โ€“ for a few years regarded as a top exponent of viral news โ€“ has been struggling to maintain its buzz of late. The cheeky and provocative โ€“ if at times annoying โ€“ provider of endless listicles and outrageous clickbait headlines is reported to have fallen into financial difficulties

The siteโ€™s founder, Jonah Peretti, is reported to have told staff: โ€œI made the decision to over-invest in BuzzFeed News because I love their work and mission so much. This made me slow to accept that the big platforms wouldnโ€™t provide the distribution or financial support required to support premium, free journalism purpose-built for social media.โ€

A decline in traffic to the site seems to have been caused by a drop in referrals from feeder sites such as Facebook. This was itself caused by a switch to its users watching and sharing more video on sites like TikTok. Less traffic means less ad revenue. And less revenue has meant the closure of Buzzfeedโ€™s news operation โ€“ itself a loss leader to give the site extra credibility โ€“ and a resultant loss of jobs for its journalists.

Itโ€™s bad news for those involved โ€“ and a tragedy for the wider digital news media. Buzzfeed News produced lots of hard-edged, scoop-heavy journalism โ€“ and it will be missed. Letโ€™s be clear: it is the valuable news division โ€“ the one that revealed the network of detention camps in Xinjiang Province in China โ€“ that is to shut. The other stuff, the user-generated free-for-all, full of videos of baby penguins being tickled and listicles setting out the best method to air-fry chips will remain โ€“ at least for now.

Buzzfeed News produced intelligent, hard-hitting journalism that frequently scooped established media organisations. It won respect and awards in equal measure.

Viral content

Buzzfeed pioneered the use of viral content and helped legitimise the practice as a form of journalism. The companyโ€™s early success โ€“ roughly a period between 2012 when it launched Buzzfeed News and early 2919 when it started laying off staff โ€“ inspired many other media companies to create viral content of their own.

In the spring of 2013, media companies were desperate to get a piece of the Buzzfeed magic. Trinity Mirror tripled its traffic practically overnight with irreverent projects such as UsVsTh3m and Ampp3d which openly aped Buzzfeedโ€™s irreverent and flippant style. The then editor of The Sun, David Dinsmore, said that Buzzfeed was โ€œthe best thing on the internetโ€ and the paper launched a similar unpaywalled product of its own. Even the BBC, in a report by the former chief executive of Sony, Sir Howard Stringer urged itself to become more distinctive โ€œlike Buzzfeedโ€. The Independentโ€™s Indy100 with its diet of quizzes, nuggets of news and eye-catching images remains the closest thing to Buzzfeed in the UK media.

Even if the wider Buzzfeed โ€“ the user-generated entertainment division, that formed our impression of Buzzfeed, with headlines such as 10 Cardboard Boxes That Look Like David Cameron and quizzes such as Which Ousted Arab Spring Ruler Are You? we should not forget the quality of its journalism. The news division did the proper journalism and won website of the year at the 2018 Society of Editors Press Awards and then scooped the Pulitzer prize in 2021 with the Xinjiang detention camps exclusive.

Journalistic values

study by Nanyang Technological University in Singapore found that BuzzFeed Newsโ€™s news values were broadly similar to those of The New York Times, with both outlets prioritising stories about government and politics. While the NYT offered more stories about crime and terrorism, Buzzfeed News offered more coverage of social issues and protests.

This is because Buzzfeed News was staffed by proper journalists who produced proper journalism. Heavy hitters including Emily Dugan, who won Private Eyeโ€™s coveted Paul Foot Award in 2019 for her persistent campaign to reveal โ€œthe human cost of the degradation of Englandโ€™s justice and legal aid systemโ€.

Buzzfeed's homepage
Cheeky, innovative, but not financially stable. chrisdorney via Shutterstock

Indeed, a 2018 study by researchers at the University of Leeds found that Buzzfeed News journalists had the instincts and values of traditional reporters, despite their relative youth and focus on issues relevant people aged 18 to 30. The study, which was published in the journal Journalism Studies, suggested that Buzzfeed News was not just a clickbait website, but a legitimate news organisation that employed journalists who were committed to the highest standards of their craft.

The closure of the news division provides a sobering reminder of the challenges facing digital journalism. The industry still struggles, two decades on, to find a sustainable business model. And no new-media organisation has been able to break the hold of the traditional news media. In Press Gazetteโ€™s March 2023 ranking of the top media sites in the world, the only โ€œnewโ€ media site to break into the top 25 was Buzzfeed News, and that was in 25th position. A sad day for journalism.

Contributor

Recently Published

Key Takeaway: Artificial intelligence (AI) is revolutionizing investment by making professional financial insight and portfolio management accessible to everyone. AI-powered robo-advisers, such as Betterment and Vanguard, are democratizing investment and providing tailored advice to a new generation of investors. With 31% of gen Zs and 20% of millennials using robo-advisers, the financial industry is adapting […]

Top Picks

Key Takeaways: Stock market enthusiasts often claim to predict financial market trends with great accuracy, but this is not possible due to the uncertainty and unpredictable nature of the environments in which we make daily decisions. Human cognition tends to favor a reductionist approach to information processing, sometimes called “tunneling,” which can lead to biased […]

Trending

I highly recommend reading the McKinsey Global Instituteโ€™s new report, โ€œReskilling China: Transforming The Worldโ€™s Largest Workforce Into Lifelong Learnersโ€, which focuses on the countryโ€™s biggest employment challenge, re-training its workforce and the adoption of practices such as lifelong learning to address the growing digital transformation of its productive fabric. How to transform the country […]

Join our Newsletter

Get our monthly recap with the latest news, articles and resources.

Login

Welcome to Empirics

We are glad you have decided to join our mission of gathering the collective knowledge of Asia!
Join Empirics