Much has been made of the concept of core competencies.  In a hypercompetitive world, a CEO can easily argue that a firm should do what it does well and outsource the functions that others do more efficiently or effectively.  Emphasis on outsourcing has grown to encompass entire business processes or entire functions.

What, then, can we say about outsourcing innovation?  If a business can readily outsource its procurement functions, or its manufacturing processes, can it, or should it, outsource its innovation functions?  And if so, to whom?

Let’s start by stipulating that few firms can claim innovation as a core competency.  If we follow the logic that a firm should outsource functions or processes that aren’t a core competency or that the firm doesn’t do well, then by all means, clearly most firms should outsource innovation.  But it certainly doesn’t seem to make much business sense to follow that dictum.  Innovation is critical to growth, profits and long term strategy.  Outsourcing innovation may lead to short term gains, but over the longer term can an innovation “outsourcer” fully understand a firm’s goals and strategies?  Does a third party offer that much better insight into your customers’ need and wants?

If we then argue that it is dangerous for a firm to outsource innovation entirely, then perhaps we can argue that certain functions can be safely outsourced to third parties with deep capabilities or experience.  We consider innovation to be an end to end process defined by these phases or steps:

  • Trend spotting and scenario planning
  • Identifying unmet or unarticulated needs
  • Idea Generation
  • Idea management, evaluation and selection
  • Prototyping
  • Concept testing
  • Commercialization

Let’s examine the possibilities of outsourcing one, or several, of these phases.

Trend Spotting and Scenario Planning

Few firms do a good job of trend spotting and scenario planning, so this is a capability that can be outsourced to third parties that understand how to collect and assimilate trends and develop scenarios.  However, any third party developing scenarios must understand your strategy, your vision, your customers and your time horizons in order to develop meaningful scenarios.  That work can’t be done in a vacuum, and your strategies and definitions must be carefully communicated to a third party, otherwise the scenarios and their implications won’t amount to much.

Identifying unmet needs

The concept of ethnography and other qualitative research can help identify unmet needs or unarticulated needs, yet few corporations have these skills in house.  This work can be outsourced to firms that specialized in identifying customer needs and wants using qualitative research tools.  However, these firms must be educated about your products, your strategies and your goals.  While ethnography and other tools can provide compelling insights, differing scope definitions, a poor understanding of your purpose or needs can create meaningless insight.

Idea Generation

Many firms assume they can outsource idea generation – to customers, consumers, business partners.  This is a reasonably safe assumption if your firm does a good job providing scope, strategy and context.  If this “framing” is provided effectively, others can generate ideas in your behalf.  If you fail to provide strategy, scope or can’t define a problem or opportunity effectively, then the people who attempt to provide you with ideas will return a large quantity of ideas, but with little applicability to your needs.

Idea management and selection

While you could conceivably outsource idea management and selection, this work should be done by people on your staff.  Picking a new product which will drive new revenue and defining the features and attributes of that product should be driven by your internal teams, in conjunction with your development teams. 

In fact, after idea generation, I’ll argue that it is exceptionally risky to outsource any step, with the possible exception of testing a potential solution with consumers.  If your product development capabilities are on par with your industry, there should be little reason to outsource anything after idea generation.

Note as well that even in the phases where it may be possible to outsource innovation work that there are several consistent caveats, mostly focused on strategy, vision and scope.  Innovation, whether accomplished with internal resources or external agents, simply can’t function effectively without these factors, well-documented and well communicated.  It won’t matter if you have leading third party consultants or an embryonic internal innovation team.  If you can’t provide clear strategy, clear guidelines and clear scope, you can’t outsource innovation.

One last barrier

Finally, let’s assume you’ve successfully outsourced innovation, and a brilliant consulting team has identified an important need, generated ideas and selected an idea for development.  Now, all that’s required is to translate that idea from the consulting team to the product or service development team.  Simple, right?

Not typically.  Product development teams have their own priorities and most likely weren’t involved in the development or generation.  Rather than seeing the consulting team as a partner in innovation, they may see them as a threat.  So it is entirely possible that good ideas originating from a renown consulting firm can’t be commercialized effectively due to a transition barrier from idea to product, external to internal.

Conclusion

While core competencies matter, and firms should stick to what they do best, it is difficult to outsource innovation effectively even in the best of circumstances.  There are certainly specific steps or phases of an innovation effort which may be outsourced without difficulty, but only if the goals and strategies are well defined.  Any firm outsourcing an entire innovation process is likely to discover it has also outsourced its strategy as well.

Written by Jeffrey Phillips. Jeffrey is a senior consultant and VP Marketing for OVO Innovation.

Recently Published

Key Takeaway: The mystery of consciousness has been a subject of debate for centuries, with numerous theories vying for the title. In 2024, the Cogitate Consortium conducted an “adversarial collaboration” between Global Neuronal Workspace Theory (GNWT) and Integrated Information Theory (IIT). The study aimed to test the theories under neutral conditions, revealing that confirmation bias […]

Top Picks

Key Takeaway: President Donald Trump’s executive order titled “Restoring Freedom of Speech and Ending Federal Censorship” accused the previous administration of stifling free expression by working with social media companies to curb misinformation and label misleading content. However, recent research suggests that less regulation can actually make the internet a less free place for speech, […]
Key Takeaway: Recent research published in Science has revealed that the brain uses multiple learning mechanisms simultaneously, revealing the complexity behind brain wiring. Neurons communicate through electric signals called synapses, which form complex networks of connections that transmit information. The traditional theory of synaptic plasticity assumes uniformity between neurons, but the new study found that […]
Key Takeaway: A new study published in Nature Astronomy claims that the James Webb Space Telescope (JWST) has detected atmospheric signals on K2-18b, a distant world 124 light-years from Earth. The researchers found traces of molecules often associated with biological activity on Earth, including dimethyl sulphide (DMS). The scientists are 99.7% confident in the presence […]
Key Takeaway: Belief in the supernatural, including ghosts, spirits, astrology, and psychic powers, is more common than people might expect. These beliefs offer a sense of control, meaning, and comfort in the face of life’s unpredictability. They fall outside the boundaries of conventional science and include ideas like fate, spiritual forces, and life after death. […]
Key Takeaway: Brain-computer interface (BCI) technology is rapidly redefining human potential, with breakthroughs in artificial intelligence and machine learning enabling the translation of thoughts into action. The brain is a complex network of over 80 billion neurons, processing thoughts, memories, emotions, and sensory inputs. Advances in AI, miniaturized electronics, and neuroimaging have led to the […]

Trending

I highly recommend reading the McKinsey Global Institute’s new report, “Reskilling China: Transforming The World’s Largest Workforce Into Lifelong Learners”, which focuses on the country’s biggest employment challenge, re-training its workforce and the adoption of practices such as lifelong learning to address the growing digital transformation of its productive fabric. How to transform the country […]

Join our Newsletter

Get our monthly recap with the latest news, articles and resources.

Login

Welcome to Empirics

We are glad you have decided to join our mission of gathering the collective knowledge of Asia!
Join Empirics