A highly critical article in The Verge, “Hey Siri, what happened?”, discusses an issue many of us have been observing for some time: that Apple’s home assistant is noticeably less intelligent and more limited than its competitors such as Alexa or Google Assistant. The usage test confirms it: ten years after Siri’s introduction, if you have, as I do, both Alexa and Google Assistant at home and Siri always in your pocket, you tend to turn to Alexa for automation issues, timers and reminders, and to Google to ask all sorts of questions, leaving Siri only for relatively isolated and specific uses. If you are in an emergency situation, don’t even try

So what happened? The explanation once given by those who know something about machine learning no longer seems to be the case: Apple is highly respectful of its users’ privacy and so would have more problems than other companies when it comes to collecting and using data to train its algorithms. However, the indications are that Apple is not so enormously respectful, given that it has been caught sending conversations with its assistant to external subcontractors who expressed astonishment at how sensitive some of the information contained in them was, and because it could, without too much trouble, pay third parties to generate those dialogues.

Apparently, the explanation why Siri lags behind by other assistants is simpler: bad management. Problems with the management team, management changes, bad decisions when, for example, linking Siri updates to the release of new products, and above all, the decision to keep the product closed and unable to interact with other non-Apple applications. You can ask Siri to do many things, but all or most of those that try to call other apps will fail miserably, while others try to make you use the company’s apps, which are not always the ones we want to use. In the end, after many frustrating attempts, you end up realizing that Siri is pretty much a one-trick pony that is good for very restricted tasks. In fact, even Apple has withdrawn some of its functionalities, without making it clear whether this is temporary or permanent.

If voice aspires to become a really useful interface to interact with our devices, perhaps Apple should remember that even its most fanatical users probably use applications or even devices made by other companies, and that its assistant should be inclusive, open to developers who can easily integrate it to provide more functionality. At this point, Siri is starting to look more and more like a lost opportunity, that of leading the intelligent assistant market only to fall behind the rest of the field. For a feature launched ten years ago by the world’s largest and most valuable company not to be a leader should prompt some head scratching at Apple HQ, along with questions as to what the company needs to do to fulfill the ambitions it expressed when it presented its voice assistant become a reality…

http://www.enriquedans.com
Contributor

Recently Published

Key Takeaway: Black holes, a potential energy source, have been the subject of theoretical research since the 1970s. The Zel’dovich Effect, a theory that rotating objects could amplify energy waves, was tested in 2020. The experiment confirmed that a rotating cylinder could amplify sound waves and electromagnetic waves, revealing similarities between the rotating cylinder and […]
Key Takeaway: Plants, once considered passive life forms, are now found to be dynamic and responsive. Researchers discovered that even seemingly insignificant behaviors, such as circumnutations, can have a profound impact on their survival and productivity. Sunflowers, for example, self-organize in a zigzag pattern to maximize sunlight exposure, promoting healthy growth and increased yield. This […]

Top Picks

Key Takeaway: China’s Chang’e 5 mission has challenged long-held assumptions about the Moon’s volcanic past, suggesting eruptions occurred far more recently than expected. The lunar landscape might not have been as dormant as once believed, with volcanic activity on the Moon potentially being active as recently as 120 million years ago. The findings suggest that […]
Key Takeaway: Sigmund Freud’s theory of sublimation aimed to explain why some people display extraordinary talent by transforming repressed sexual desires into creative or intellectual prowess. He believed that Leonardo da Vinci’s life and work exemplified this process, as he left many of his paintings unfinished and engaged in scientific experiments that derailed his artistic […]
Key Takeaway: High-altitude platform stations (HAPS) are emerging as a new frontier in communications technology, offering a unique blend of accessibility and affordability. Positioned between 4 and 30 miles above Earth, these stations bring telecommunications equipment closer to the surface than satellites, resulting in stronger, higher-capacity signals. Researchers have demonstrated that HAPS could provide high-speed […]
Key Takeaway: Horse domestication remains a mystery, despite its significant impact on human civilization. The Indo-European or “Kurgan hypothesis” suggests that horse domestication began on the steppes of western Asia, specifically among the Yamnaya people. However, recent advances in technology have revealed that the horses from the Botai culture were not the ancestors of today’s […]
Key Takeaway: A study by researchers has found that companies can make a difference without sacrificing financial performance by integrating social and environmental concerns into their business strategies. This approach, known as “social profit orientation,” places equal value on financial profits and positive social outcomes. Companies like Mastercard’s Girls4Tech initiative and World Central Kitchen’s Food […]

Trending

I highly recommend reading the McKinsey Global Institute’s new report, “Reskilling China: Transforming The World’s Largest Workforce Into Lifelong Learners”, which focuses on the country’s biggest employment challenge, re-training its workforce and the adoption of practices such as lifelong learning to address the growing digital transformation of its productive fabric. How to transform the country […]

Join our Newsletter

Get our monthly recap with the latest news, articles and resources.

Login

Welcome to Empirics

We are glad you have decided to join our mission of gathering the collective knowledge of Asia!
Join Empirics